Carrefour France’s decision to suspend the sale of meat from Mercosur countries, including Brazil, has caused strong outrage and prompted strong responses from agricultural sector entities. The announcement, made by CEO Alexandre Bompard, mentioned concerns related to sustainability and deforestation, but was widely criticized as protectionist and technically unfounded.
Agricultural sector criticizes decision as harmful and uninformed
The Agriculture and Livestock Federation of the State of São Paulo (Faesp) highlighted the negative impacts of the measure, both for trade between Brazil and France and for the reputation of Brazilian meat. Furthermore, national meat, recognized worldwide for its quality and sustainable practices, was defended by the president of Faesp, Tirso Meirelles:
“Brazilian meat is one of the most sustainable and competitive products on the planet. Therefore, this decision demonstrates a protectionist and uninformed attitude. Therefore, we hope that Carrefour will review its stance and publicly retract its decision.”
Agricultural entities reaffirm the sustainability of Brazilian production
The Instituto Desenvolve Pecuária also expressed dissatisfaction with Carrefour's position, highlighting Brazil's progress in integrating efficient production and environmental preservation. The entity reinforced that Brazilian environmental legislation is among the strictest in the world, and that the sector continually invests in technologies to minimize environmental impacts.
Likewise, Delta G Connection emphasized Brazil's strategic role in global food security, supplying meat to demanding markets such as the United States, Europe and Asia.
“The decision disregards Brazil’s role in the global food chain and goes against the principles of free trade and international cooperation,” said Conexão Delta G. The entity requested that Carrefour prioritize dialogue and review its decision.
Ministry of Agriculture responds to Carrefour's statements
The Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock (Mapa) also took a position, reaffirming that Brazil is the world's largest exporter of beef and poultry. The ministry highlighted the strict controls applied to national production and the sector's commitment to sustainable practices.
In an official statement, Mapa condemned any attempt to belittle the quality of Brazilian products:
“Brazil remains committed to excellent environmental and health practices. We will not accept actions that harm the country’s image.”
Sustainability and global trade at the center of the debate
Carrefour France's decision exposes trade tensions between Mercosur and the European Union, reigniting discussions about sustainability and production standards. While Carrefour justifies its position with environmental concerns, Brazilian entities emphasize that the country is a global reference in sustainability in livestock farming.
The episode highlights the need for more transparent and collaborative dialogue between trading blocs to address common challenges and promote sustainable development.
Source: Aline Merladete | agrolink